

Sheldon Victorine, MS, ATC, CSCS
Published November 20, 2026
A Q&A this week, written for you if you supervise people. These aren’t reader submissions yet. They’re five questions I’d expect a reasonable supervisor to ask the week a worker comes back after a concussion (mild traumatic brain injury, mTBI), answered from published guidance and research. If you have a real question you want answered in a future Q&A, you can send it through the contact page. Please leave out anything that identifies your employer or your workers.
This expanded version is for supervisors, safety teams, occupational health nurses, occupational medicine physicians, and athletic trainers working in industry who get asked these questions on the floor and need a careful answer about whose call each one is.
Educational content for workplace safety teams. It is not medical advice and does not replace evaluation by a licensed health care professional. Industrial Concussion Institute supports recognition, escalation, documentation and clinician-led disposition. It does not diagnose, clear workers or issue return-to-work authorization. ICAT is a recognition and referral tool, not a diagnostic instrument.
Key takeaways
The decision about whether a worker can return, and on what terms, belongs to the treating clinician, not to the supervisor and not to me.
The ACOEM Traumatic Brain Injury guideline (2025 edition, publicly posted by California’s Division of Workers’ Compensation) recommends return to work or activities without a significant risk of repeat TBI, “generally earlier than later” (Evidence C, moderate confidence). The speed of return should be based on the worker’s current cognitive and physical status compared with the job’s demands. Most people with mild TBI may return “in some capacity,” with close follow-up to adjust as tolerated. Safety-critical work gets added caution (ACOEM, 2025).
The Ontario living concussion guideline separates two words that often get blurred in a work note. Restrictions are about safety risk, like no working at heights when balance is impaired. Limitations are about capacity, like limiting screens or noise when those make symptoms worse. The clinician identifies them. The employer reviews job demands and finds accommodations (Concussions Ontario, 2024).
In a Danish study of employees with persistent symptoms lasting more than four weeks after a concussion, about three-fourths had returned to work, but only about a third under similar conditions to before. Average weekly hours dropped from 36.3 to 17.6. Workers described needing more breaks and struggling with multitasking and work speed. That group does not describe everyone (Conradsen et al., 2024).
An Ontario workers’ compensation study compared workers with mild TBI claims who started mental-health treatment within three months with matched workers who started later. The early group had lower average costs and shorter disability, but the differences were not statistically significant. The authors concluded early intervention “may” help. That is a signal, not proof (Nanwa et al., 2022).
Workers have described stalls at the employer, the family doctor, and municipal case management, often all at once (Graff et al., 2021). Teachers in a New Zealand study described feeling isolated trying to link everyone together themselves (McCleary et al., 2026). I don’t think there’s one right owner. My view is that there should be one named person, and the worker shouldn’t be the one doing it alone.
1. “Can I just send him back today?”
That isn’t the supervisor’s call, and it isn’t mine.
That isn’t the supervisor’s call, and it isn’t mine. It belongs to the treating clinician.
What the guidance says may still surprise people. The ACOEM Traumatic Brain Injury guideline, in its 2025 edition as publicly posted by California’s Division of Workers’ Compensation, recommends return to work or activities without a significant risk of repeat TBI, “generally earlier than later.” That recommendation is graded Evidence C, with moderate confidence. The guideline also says the speed of return should be based on the worker’s current cognitive and physical status compared with the job’s demands, and that most people with mild TBI may return “in some capacity,” with close follow-up to adjust as tolerated. Safety-critical work gets added caution (ACOEM, 2025).
Read those lines together and the surprise sits next to a limit. “Earlier than later” is not the same as “back to the full job today.” “In some capacity” is a real option, and it is also a narrower one than a full-duty return. Close follow-up is part of the recommendation, not an optional extra. And safety-critical work is called out for added caution, which is another way of saying the job’s demands belong in the decision.
So the honest answer is: maybe back soon, probably not to the full job on day one, and with someone checking how it goes. The someone making that call is the treating clinician. The supervisor’s job is to ask for a usable note, apply what it says to the actual work, and make sure follow-up has a place to land.
2. “The note just says ‘light duty.’ What do I do with that?”
Ask for two words instead: restrictions and limitations.
The Ontario living concussion guideline, last updated in April 2024, separates them in Tables 12.1 and 12.2. Restrictions are about safety risk, like no working at heights when balance is impaired. Limitations are about capacity, like limiting screens or noise when those make symptoms worse. The guideline gives the clinician the job of identifying them and gives the employer the job of reviewing job demands and finding accommodations (Concussions Ontario, 2024).
That split is practical. A restriction draws a line the worker should not cross because of risk, to themselves or to other people. A limitation describes what the worker can currently do, and for how long, before symptoms get in the way. “Light duty” blurs both. It doesn’t tell you whether the problem is heights, screens, noise, lifting, or shift length, and it doesn’t tell you who is supposed to solve it.
I’ve written about this distinction in a short field note. That earlier note is not live on this site yet, so I’ll keep the point here: if a note only says “light duty,” it is fair to go back and ask the clinician to name the restrictions and the limitations in plain language. Then the employer’s job is the one the guideline already assigns: look at the job demands and find accommodations that fit.
3. “He’s back, but he’s slower. Is that normal?”
For some workers, yes. That’s not a reason to ignore it.
A Danish study of employees with persistent symptoms after a concussion found that about three-fourths had returned to work, but only about a third under similar conditions to before. Average weekly hours dropped from 36.3 to 17.6. Workers described needing more breaks and struggling with multitasking and work speed (Conradsen et al., 2024).

In one Danish study, average weekly hours fell by about half.
That group had symptoms lasting more than four weeks, so it doesn’t describe everyone. People who recover on a shorter timeline are not in this picture, and the study should not be read as a forecast for every return. But “back and slower” is a known pattern in workers who are still symptomatic, and it’s worth telling the clinician about.
If you supervise that person, the useful move is not to decide whether the slower pace is acceptable. It is to notice it, document what you’re seeing in ordinary language, and make sure the treating clinician has that information when the next adjustment is made. Hours, breaks, multitasking, and work speed are exactly the kind of floor-level detail a work note can miss.
4. “Should mental-health support wait until the physical side is sorted out?”
The evidence here is a signal, not proof, so I’ll say it carefully.
An Ontario workers’ compensation study compared workers with mild TBI claims who started mental-health treatment within three months with matched workers who started later. The early group had lower average costs and shorter disability, but the differences weren’t statistically significant. The authors concluded early intervention “may” help (Nanwa et al., 2022).
That wording matters. “May” is the authors’ word, and the lack of statistical significance is part of the finding, not a footnote to skip. I am not going to turn this study into a claim that early mental-health support is proven to shorten disability or cut costs. I’m also not going to use it as a reason to delay support until everything else is settled.
What I take from it: there’s no good reason to make a worker wait. If stress or mood is part of the picture, make sure they know what support exists, including an Employee Assistance Program if your site has one.

Mood and stress can be part of recovery too. Photo: Brian Jiz / Pexels
A supervisor is not the treating clinician, and an EAP is not a substitute for clinical care. The useful move is narrower: don’t put mental-health support at the back of the line, and don’t leave the worker to discover those options alone.
5. “Who’s supposed to connect all the pieces?”
This one comes up again and again in the research.
Workers in a Danish interview study described stalls at the employer, the family doctor, and municipal case management, often all at once (Graff et al., 2021). Teachers in a New Zealand study described feeling isolated trying to link everyone together themselves (McCleary et al., 2026).
Those are two different settings, and I am not treating them as one dataset. What they share is the coordination problem. The clinician, the employer, and whichever system is managing the claim can each be moving, and the worker can still be the person holding the connections together. That is a lot to ask of someone who is already slower, more sensitive to noise or screens, or still waiting on a usable work note.
I don’t think there’s one right owner. Different sites will place that role in occupational health, a supervisor, a claims contact, or someone else. That part is a judgment about the workplace, not a finding from these papers.
But there should be one named person, and the worker shouldn’t be the one doing it alone.
But there should be one named person, and the worker shouldn’t be the one doing it alone. That part I feel strongly about. It is my view, not a guideline recommendation.

Someone on site should own the link between clinician, employer and worker. Photo: Mikael Blomkvist / Pexels
The thread through all five
None of these answers turn a supervisor into a clinician. They’re about knowing whose call each question is, asking better questions, and making sure the answers actually reach the floor.
The first question belongs to the treating clinician. The second is a request for a clearer note, and then an employer task: match restrictions and limitations to the job. The third is a pattern worth reporting, not a clearance decision. The fourth is a reason not to make support wait. The fifth is a coordination problem that should have a name attached to it.
How this page relates to ICAT
Industrial Concussion Institute is working on the workplace side of this question. ICAT is a structured recognition and referral tool for trained first aiders and safety teams. It does not diagnose concussion, and it does not clear anyone to return to work. Medical disposition and restrictions belong to an appropriately licensed healthcare professional. The employer applies those restrictions to the job.
The sources behind ICI articles are collected on the Research page.
The question underneath
Which of these five comes up most where you work?
Please leave out anything that identifies your employer or your workers. You can share a de-identified question through the contact page. I read every response.
Sources
American College of Occupational and Environmental Medicine (ACOEM). Traumatic Brain Injury Guideline. In: ACOEM Practice Guidelines, Traumatic Brain Injury Guideline. Reed Group; 2025. Public copy adopted in the California DWC MTUS (August 2025 update): https://www.dir.ca.gov/dwc/DWCPropRegs/2025/MTUS-Evidence-Based-Update-August/Traumatic-Brain-Injury-Guideline.pdf
Concussions Ontario. Living Concussion Guidelines, Tables 12.1–12.2 (last updated April 2024).
Conradsen I, Bang-Hansen VE, Sørensen AN, Rytter HM. Return to work in persons with persistent postconcussion symptoms: a survey study examining the perspectives of employees and managers. Brain Inj. 2024;38(11):908-917 (DOI 10.1080/02699052.2024.2361620; PMID 38828860).
Nanwa N, Wong V, Thompson AMS. Impact of Timing of Mental Health Interventions for Mild Traumatic Brain Injury Patients: A 10-year Matched Cohort Study of Workers’ Compensation Claims. J Occup Environ Med. 2022;64(6):458-464 (DOI 10.1097/JOM.0000000000002512; PMID 35761423).
Graff HJ, Deleu NW, Christiansen P, Rytter HM. Facilitators of and barriers to return to work after mild traumatic brain injury: A thematic analysis. Neuropsychol Rehabil. 2021;31(9):1349-1373 (DOI 10.1080/09602011.2020.1778489; PMID 32584206).
McCleary RE, Martin RA, Snell DL. Barriers and facilitators experienced by primary school teachers returning to work after mild traumatic brain injury in Aotearoa, New Zealand. Brain Impair. 2026;27(2):IB25114 (DOI 10.1071/IB25114; PMID 42177662).

About the author
Sheldon Victorine, MS, ATC, CSCS, is the Founder and Lead Researcher of the Industrial Concussion Institute. He specializes in workplace health, safety and ergonomics, with a clinical foundation as a certified athletic trainer and NSCA Certified Strength and Conditioning Specialist, after 7 years in the U.S. Navy. He writes evidence-informed tools and training that help workplaces recognize head injuries, refer workers to care and document what happened.