Industrial Concussion
Institute
Essay cover: the S in SCAT stands for sport. What are we adapting when we borrow it?

The “S” in SCAT Stands for Sport

The “S” in SCAT Stands for Sport

What are we adapting when we borrow it?

What are we adapting when we borrow it?

Portrait of Sheldon Victorine, MS, ATC, CSCS

Sheldon Victorine, MS, ATC, CSCS

Published November 12, 2026

Listen to this article--:--

The Sport Concussion Assessment Tool announces its intended population in its first word.

The Sport Concussion Assessment Tool announces its intended population in its first word.

I don’t say that as a criticism. If you’re an athletic trainer, you know the SCAT well. I think the current version, SCAT6, is among the most carefully built instruments in concussion care. That care is exactly why the first word matters. A tool built this deliberately for one population raises a fair question about every other population it gets used with.

I don’t say that as a criticism. If you’re an athletic trainer, you know the SCAT well. I think the current version, SCAT6, is among the most carefully built instruments in concussion care. That care is exactly why the first word matters. A tool built this deliberately for one population raises a fair question about every other population it gets used with.

For work-related concussion (mild traumatic brain injury, mTBI), the question is simple to ask and hard to answer: what is the workplace equivalent?

For work-related concussion (mild traumatic brain injury, mTBI), the question is simple to ask and hard to answer: what is the workplace equivalent?

This expanded version is for safety teams, occupational health nurses, occupational medicine physicians, athletic trainers working in industry, and first aiders who see a sport-derived screening result show up in a workplace file and need to know what it was built to carry.

This expanded version is for safety teams, occupational health nurses, occupational medicine physicians, athletic trainers working in industry, and first aiders who see a sport-derived screening result show up in a workplace file and need to know what it was built to carry.

Educational content for workplace safety teams. It is not medical advice and does not replace evaluation by a licensed health care professional. Industrial Concussion Institute supports recognition, escalation, documentation and clinician-led disposition. It does not diagnose, clear workers or issue return-to-work authorization. ICAT is a recognition and referral tool, not a diagnostic instrument.

Educational content for workplace safety teams. It is not medical advice and does not replace evaluation by a licensed health care professional. Industrial Concussion Institute supports recognition, escalation, documentation and clinician-led disposition. It does not diagnose, clear workers or issue return-to-work authorization. ICAT is a recognition and referral tool, not a diagnostic instrument.

Key takeaways

  • SCAT6 is designed for healthcare professionals assessing sport-related concussion in athletes aged 13 and older, ideally within 72 hours of injury and up to 7 days. It says it is “not intended to be used as a stand-alone diagnostic tool” (Echemendia et al., 2023).

  • SCAT6 is designed for healthcare professionals assessing sport-related concussion in athletes aged 13 and older, ideally within 72 hours of injury and up to 7 days. It says it is “not intended to be used as a stand-alone diagnostic tool” (Echemendia et al., 2023).

  • The Amsterdam consensus statement behind SCAT6 was written for healthcare professionals caring for athletes and says it is not a clinical practice directive or legal standard of care (Patricios et al., 2023).

  • The SCAT has been revised through more than two decades of Concussion in Sport Group meetings, from Vienna in 2001 to Amsterdam in 2022 (Aubry et al., 2002; McCrory et al., 2005).

  • The SCAT6 Maddocks questions are about venue, game half, and scores. The form allows sport-specific substitutions. At a work site, anyone using that section is writing their own questions.

  • The ACOEM traumatic brain injury guideline (2025) moderately recommends the SCAT to screen patients with possible TBI, calls it a screening tool and not a diagnostic tool, and notes that baseline testing would rarely be indicated in occupational settings (ACOEM, 2025).

  • Without a baseline, parts of the test, such as balance, are often read against published reference data from some population. In healthy military personnel who were not acutely concussed, 36.5% scored above one study’s mBESS cutoff (Kontos et al., 2022). In 1,234 adults aged 20 to 69, mBESS performance declined with age (Iverson & Koehle, 2013). Neither group is an industrial workforce.

  • Adapting a tool is a reasonable clinical judgment call. The practice recommendation in this article is to name the adaptation in writing.

  • The Amsterdam consensus statement behind SCAT6 was written for healthcare professionals caring for athletes and says it is not a clinical practice directive or legal standard of care (Patricios et al., 2023).

  • The SCAT has been revised through more than two decades of Concussion in Sport Group meetings, from Vienna in 2001 to Amsterdam in 2022 (Aubry et al., 2002; McCrory et al., 2005).

  • The SCAT6 Maddocks questions are about venue, game half, and scores. The form allows sport-specific substitutions. At a work site, anyone using that section is writing their own questions.

  • The ACOEM traumatic brain injury guideline (2025) moderately recommends the SCAT to screen patients with possible TBI, calls it a screening tool and not a diagnostic tool, and notes that baseline testing would rarely be indicated in occupational settings (ACOEM, 2025).

  • Without a baseline, parts of the test, such as balance, are often read against published reference data from some population. In healthy military personnel who were not acutely concussed, 36.5% scored above one study’s mBESS cutoff (Kontos et al., 2022). In 1,234 adults aged 20 to 69, mBESS performance declined with age (Iverson & Koehle, 2013). Neither group is an industrial workforce.

  • Adapting a tool is a reasonable clinical judgment call. The practice recommendation in this article is to name the adaptation in writing.

What SCAT6 says about itself

What SCAT6 says about itself

I’ll start with the tool’s own documentation, because it’s unusually clear about scope.

I’ll start with the tool’s own documentation, because it’s unusually clear about scope.

SCAT6 is designed for healthcare professionals assessing sport-related concussion in athletes aged 13 and older. A separate Child SCAT6 covers ages 8 to 12. It is meant to be used in the acute phase, ideally within 72 hours of injury and up to 7 days. And it describes itself carefully: it is “not intended to be used as a stand-alone diagnostic tool but rather to inform clinical assessment and diagnosis” (Echemendia et al., 2023).

SCAT6 is designed for healthcare professionals assessing sport-related concussion in athletes aged 13 and older. A separate Child SCAT6 covers ages 8 to 12. It is meant to be used in the acute phase, ideally within 72 hours of injury and up to 7 days. And it describes itself carefully: it is “not intended to be used as a stand-alone diagnostic tool but rather to inform clinical assessment and diagnosis” (Echemendia et al., 2023).

Past the acute window, sport built a different instrument. The Sport Concussion Office Assessment Tool 6 (SCOAT6) supports multimodal, office-based assessment by healthcare professionals from 72 hours after injury onward (Patricios et al., 2023, SCOAT6).

Past the acute window, sport built a different instrument. The Sport Concussion Office Assessment Tool 6 (SCOAT6) supports multimodal, office-based assessment by healthcare professionals from 72 hours after injury onward (Patricios et al., 2023, SCOAT6).

The consensus statement behind both tools is just as clear about who it serves. It was “developed for the healthcare professional (HCP) involved in the care of athletes” at any level of sport, recreational to professional. It also says plainly that it “is not intended as a clinical practice directive or legal standard of care” (Patricios et al., 2023).

The consensus statement behind both tools is just as clear about who it serves. It was “developed for the healthcare professional (HCP) involved in the care of athletes” at any level of sport, recreational to professional. It also says plainly that it “is not intended as a clinical practice directive or legal standard of care” (Patricios et al., 2023).

Scope card with two panels: SCAT6, athletes 13 and older, acute phase, ideally within 72 hours; SCOAT6, office-based, from 72 hours on.

Read together, those lines describe a tool that knows exactly who it’s for. The age range covers adult workers. The setting it was built around doesn’t.

Read together, those lines describe a tool that knows exactly who it’s for. The age range covers adult workers. The setting it was built around doesn’t.

That distinction is worth slowing down on. Age is a property of the person. Setting is a property of the decision. A 40-year-old electrician and a 40-year-old recreational soccer player are both inside SCAT6’s age range. Only one of them is in the setting the tool was designed around, and only one of them is headed toward a decision about returning to sport.

That distinction is worth slowing down on. Age is a property of the person. Setting is a property of the decision. A 40-year-old electrician and a 40-year-old recreational soccer player are both inside SCAT6’s age range. Only one of them is in the setting the tool was designed around, and only one of them is headed toward a decision about returning to sport.

More than two decades of building for one population

More than two decades of building for one population

Here’s what makes SCAT6 credible to me: the process behind it.

Here’s what makes SCAT6 credible to me: the process behind it.

The Concussion in Sport Group held its first international conference in Vienna in 2001 (Aubry et al., 2002). The original SCAT came out of the second conference, in Prague in 2004 (McCrory et al., 2005). The tool was then revised at every meeting since: SCAT2 after Zurich in 2008, SCAT3 after Zurich in 2012, SCAT5 after Berlin in 2016, and SCAT6 after Amsterdam in 2022.

The Concussion in Sport Group held its first international conference in Vienna in 2001 (Aubry et al., 2002). The original SCAT came out of the second conference, in Prague in 2004 (McCrory et al., 2005). The tool was then revised at every meeting since: SCAT2 after Zurich in 2008, SCAT3 after Zurich in 2012, SCAT5 after Berlin in 2016, and SCAT6 after Amsterdam in 2022.

Timeline of Concussion in Sport Group meetings: Vienna 2001 first conference, Prague 2004 original SCAT, Zurich 2008 SCAT2, Zurich 2012 SCAT3, Berlin 2016 SCAT5, Amsterdam 2022 SCAT6.

From Vienna in 2001 to Amsterdam in 2022, each SCAT version followed a consensus meeting.

From Vienna in 2001 to Amsterdam in 2022, each SCAT version followed a consensus meeting.

That’s more than two decades of consensus work, systematic reviews, and revision, aimed primarily at one population and its decisions: whether an athlete may have a concussion, and how their recovery is tracked toward a return to learning and to sport.

That’s more than two decades of consensus work, systematic reviews, and revision, aimed primarily at one population and its decisions: whether an athlete may have a concussion, and how their recovery is tracked toward a return to learning and to sport.

Workers deserve that same kind of trajectory. That isn’t a claim that sport got something wrong. It’s an observation about what sustained, population-specific work produces.

Workers deserve that same kind of trajectory. That isn’t a claim that sport got something wrong. It’s an observation about what sustained, population-specific work produces.

Workers deserve that same kind of trajectory.

Workers deserve that same kind of trajectory.

Sport is not the only group that has gone this route. In 2018, the U.S. military developed the Military Acute Concussion Evaluation 2 (MACE-2) to inform the acute evaluation of mTBI in service members (Kontos et al., 2022). I’m not holding up the MACE-2 as a workplace answer. I mention it because it shows what a population that takes concussion seriously tends to do over time: build or adapt an instrument around its own people, its own settings, and its own decisions.

Sport is not the only group that has gone this route. In 2018, the U.S. military developed the Military Acute Concussion Evaluation 2 (MACE-2) to inform the acute evaluation of mTBI in service members (Kontos et al., 2022). I’m not holding up the MACE-2 as a workplace answer. I mention it because it shows what a population that takes concussion seriously tends to do over time: build or adapt an instrument around its own people, its own settings, and its own decisions.

What the tool actually contains

What the tool actually contains

It helps to remember what a SCAT is made of. The ACOEM guideline describes the SCAT5’s components as symptoms, the Glasgow Coma Scale, the Standardized Assessment of Concussion (SAC) cognitive assessment, the Maddocks questions, and an evaluation of balance and coordination. It also notes that SCAT5 scores can be summed, but there is no normal score or cutoff point (ACOEM, 2025). The balance portion starts with the modified Balance Error Scoring System (mBESS), the firm-surface version of the BESS (Echemendia et al., 2023).

It helps to remember what a SCAT is made of. The ACOEM guideline describes the SCAT5’s components as symptoms, the Glasgow Coma Scale, the Standardized Assessment of Concussion (SAC) cognitive assessment, the Maddocks questions, and an evaluation of balance and coordination. It also notes that SCAT5 scores can be summed, but there is no normal score or cutoff point (ACOEM, 2025). The balance portion starts with the modified Balance Error Scoring System (mBESS), the firm-surface version of the BESS (Echemendia et al., 2023).

That matters for workplaces in two ways. First, the SCAT is a structured set of observations, not a single pass or fail number. Second, each piece carries assumptions from the population it was developed in. Some pieces travel well. Some need translation. One of them shows its origin in plain language.

That matters for workplaces in two ways. First, the SCAT is a structured set of observations, not a single pass or fail number. Second, each piece carries assumptions from the population it was developed in. Some pieces travel well. Some need translation. One of them shows its origin in plain language.

The first word shows up inside the form

The first word shows up inside the form

You can see the population in the tool’s details, not only in its name.

You can see the population in the tool’s details, not only in its name.

An athletic trainer kneels beside a seated football player on a sideline bench at night, checking his eyes with a penlight under stadium lights.

SCAT6 was built around the field, where everyone nearby knows the score. Illustration: AI-generated for ICI

SCAT6 was built around the field, where everyone nearby knows the score. Illustration: AI-generated for ICI

SCAT6 checks memory with the Maddocks questions: “What venue are we at today?” “Which half is it now?” “Who scored last in this match?” “What team did you play last week/game?” “Did your team win the last game?” The form says the questions should be “modified appropriately for each sport,” and that “appropriate sport-specific questions may be substituted” (Echemendia et al., 2023).

SCAT6 checks memory with the Maddocks questions: “What venue are we at today?” “Which half is it now?” “Who scored last in this match?” “What team did you play last week/game?” “Did your team win the last game?” The form says the questions should be “modified appropriately for each sport,” and that “appropriate sport-specific questions may be substituted” (Echemendia et al., 2023).

That’s a smart design for a sideline. The questions have answers everyone nearby knows, so an evaluator can check the responses on the spot. But the permission the form gives is to swap one sport’s questions for another’s. At a work site there’s no half, no score, and no opponent from last week. If you use this part of the form there, you’re already writing your own questions.

That’s a smart design for a sideline. The questions have answers everyone nearby knows, so an evaluator can check the responses on the spot. But the permission the form gives is to swap one sport’s questions for another’s. At a work site there’s no half, no score, and no opponent from last week. If you use this part of the form there, you’re already writing your own questions.

Two-panel card: the sideline panel shows the question 'Which half is it now?'; the work site panel shows a question mark and blank lines.

Those questions haven’t been through the same development process. That doesn’t make them wrong. It does make them different, and the difference usually goes unrecorded.

Those questions haven’t been through the same development process. That doesn’t make them wrong. It does make them different, and the difference usually goes unrecorded.

I’m deliberately not offering substitute workplace questions here. Writing them well is development work, and it deserves the same care the sport versions received. The point of this section is narrower: the moment a sport question is swapped for a work question, the tool in use is no longer exactly the tool that was studied.

I’m deliberately not offering substitute workplace questions here. Writing them well is development work, and it deserves the same care the sport versions received. The point of this section is narrower: the moment a sport question is swapped for a work question, the tool in use is no longer exactly the tool that was studied.

What happens when the tool leaves the field

What happens when the tool leaves the field

In practice, workplace concussion assessment may involve adapting a sport-derived tool. That means an instrument developed and studied mainly in a different population, used in a setting it wasn’t designed for, and feeding into a return-to-work process with different demands, where the treating clinician makes the call.

In practice, workplace concussion assessment may involve adapting a sport-derived tool. That means an instrument developed and studied mainly in a different population, used in a setting it wasn’t designed for, and feeding into a return-to-work process with different demands, where the treating clinician makes the call.

Occupational guidance has engaged with this directly. The ACOEM practice guideline on traumatic brain injury (2025) recommends the SCAT to screen patients with possible TBI, rated “Moderately Recommended.” It calls the SCAT “a screening evaluative tool and not a diagnostic tool,” and notes that “while developed for sports settings, it has been successfully implemented in emergency departments.” It also notes that “baseline, pre-TBI testing would rarely be indicated in occupational settings” (ACOEM, 2025).

Occupational guidance has engaged with this directly. The ACOEM practice guideline on traumatic brain injury (2025) recommends the SCAT to screen patients with possible TBI, rated “Moderately Recommended.” It calls the SCAT “a screening evaluative tool and not a diagnostic tool,” and notes that “while developed for sports settings, it has been successfully implemented in emergency departments.” It also notes that “baseline, pre-TBI testing would rarely be indicated in occupational settings” (ACOEM, 2025).

The same guideline is candid about the limits. It lists the potential harm of the SCAT as occasional misinterpretation, “especially where baseline data are missing.” It notes one study that found differences by age and gender, which can make interpretation more challenging, and a low-quality study that found challenges administering the SCAT in an emergency department because of its length and interruptions (ACOEM, 2025).

The same guideline is candid about the limits. It lists the potential harm of the SCAT as occasional misinterpretation, “especially where baseline data are missing.” It notes one study that found differences by age and gender, which can make interpretation more challenging, and a low-quality study that found challenges administering the SCAT in an emergency department because of its length and interruptions (ACOEM, 2025).

ACOEM applies the same population lens to other tools. For ImPACT, a computerized test, it notes that nearly all data come from adolescent or young adult athletes, “raising questions about the applicability to occupational settings,” and it does not recommend ImPACT to screen typical occupational patients (ACOEM, 2025). That is occupational guidance doing exactly what this essay asks: checking who a tool was studied in before trusting it with workers.

ACOEM applies the same population lens to other tools. For ImPACT, a computerized test, it notes that nearly all data come from adolescent or young adult athletes, “raising questions about the applicability to occupational settings,” and it does not recommend ImPACT to screen typical occupational patients (ACOEM, 2025). That is occupational guidance doing exactly what this essay asks: checking who a tool was studied in before trusting it with workers.

The baseline problem at work

The baseline problem at work

That baseline line matters more than it looks. Sport can often test athletes before a season. Most workplaces won’t have a pre-injury score to compare against. The SCAT as a whole has no single normal score or cutoff (ACOEM, 2025), but some of its parts, such as the balance test, are often read against published reference data when no baseline exists. That reference then becomes part of the interpretation, and it has to come from somewhere.

That baseline line matters more than it looks. Sport can often test athletes before a season. Most workplaces won’t have a pre-injury score to compare against. The SCAT as a whole has no single normal score or cutoff (ACOEM, 2025), but some of its parts, such as the balance test, are often read against published reference data when no baseline exists. That reference then becomes part of the interpretation, and it has to come from somewhere.

Population shapes those references. In normative data from 1,234 adults aged 20 to 69 who completed a preventive health screen, mBESS performance declined with age (Iverson & Koehle, 2013).

Population shapes those references. In normative data from 1,234 adults aged 20 to 69 who completed a preventive health screen, mBESS performance declined with age (Iverson & Koehle, 2013).

In a 2022 study of 416 healthy U.S. Army Special Operations personnel who were not acutely concussed, 36.5% scored above the study’s mBESS cutoff of more than four total errors. Individual items on the Vestibular/Ocular Motor Screening (VOMS) produced false-positive rates from 10.6% to 17.5%. In the authors’ multivariable models, older age and a history of migraine or motion sickness predicted VOMS false positives, and a history of motion sickness was the only significant predictor of mBESS false positives (Kontos et al., 2022).

In a 2022 study of 416 healthy U.S. Army Special Operations personnel who were not acutely concussed, 36.5% scored above the study’s mBESS cutoff of more than four total errors. Individual items on the Vestibular/Ocular Motor Screening (VOMS) produced false-positive rates from 10.6% to 17.5%. In the authors’ multivariable models, older age and a history of migraine or motion sickness predicted VOMS false positives, and a history of motion sickness was the only significant predictor of mBESS false positives (Kontos et al., 2022).

Neither study is about industrial workers, and I’m not suggesting their numbers transfer. The point is narrower. The same test can behave differently in different groups. A workforce that runs from early career to late career, with its own health histories and physical demands, is a different reference group from the one most sport tools grew up with.

Neither study is about industrial workers, and I’m not suggesting their numbers transfer. The point is narrower. The same test can behave differently in different groups. A workforce that runs from early career to late career, with its own health histories and physical demands, is a different reference group from the one most sport tools grew up with.

The same test can behave differently in different groups.

The same test can behave differently in different groups.

For a closer look at the balance piece, including false positives, fatigue, and practice effects, see When Healthy Adults Fail the Balance Test.

For a closer look at the balance piece, including false positives, fatigue, and practice effects, see When Healthy Adults Fail the Balance Test.

Return to sport is not the same decision as return to work

Return to sport is not the same decision as return to work

Then there’s the decision itself. Return to sport has a structured, well-described pathway (Patricios et al., 2023). Return-to-work asks different questions. Can this person work at height, drive a route, run equipment, or finish a twelve-hour shift where a lapse in attention carries risk for other people? A score built to help a clinician in the acute window can contribute to that picture. It wasn’t designed to answer it alone, and its own documentation says so.

Then there’s the decision itself. Return to sport has a structured, well-described pathway (Patricios et al., 2023). Return-to-work asks different questions. Can this person work at height, drive a route, run equipment, or finish a twelve-hour shift where a lapse in attention carries risk for other people? A score built to help a clinician in the acute window can contribute to that picture. It wasn’t designed to answer it alone, and its own documentation says so.

The people around the decision are different too. On a sideline, the clinician, the athlete, and often the team share one goal and one calendar. At work, the decision runs through a treating provider, an employer who applies restrictions to a specific job, and in many cases a workers’ compensation process. None of those parties appear in SCAT6’s design brief, because they were never part of the population it was built for.

The people around the decision are different too. On a sideline, the clinician, the athlete, and often the team share one goal and one calendar. At work, the decision runs through a treating provider, an employer who applies restrictions to a specific job, and in many cases a workers’ compensation process. None of those parties appear in SCAT6’s design brief, because they were never part of the population it was built for.

For how concussion at work differs from sport more broadly, see Workplace Concussion: What Safety Teams Should Know. For the first minutes after a head strike, see Head Injuries at Work: What to Do in the First Minutes.

For how concussion at work differs from sport more broadly, see Workplace Concussion: What Safety Teams Should Know. For the first minutes after a head strike, see Head Injuries at Work: What to Do in the First Minutes.

Adaptation isn’t wrong

Adaptation isn’t wrong

This is the part I most want you to hear. Adapting a tool isn’t a failure of practice. It’s what capable clinicians do when the purpose-built option isn’t in front of them. Athletic trainers working in industry, occupational health nurses, and occupational medicine physicians make careful judgment calls with the instruments they have, and the ACOEM recommendation shows that occupational guidance has weighed in too.

This is the part I most want you to hear. Adapting a tool isn’t a failure of practice. It’s what capable clinicians do when the purpose-built option isn’t in front of them. Athletic trainers working in industry, occupational health nurses, and occupational medicine physicians make careful judgment calls with the instruments they have, and the ACOEM recommendation shows that occupational guidance has weighed in too.

A clinician in a white coat holding a clipboard listens as a patient in a pink sweater gestures while explaining.

Adapting a tool is a clinical judgment call. Naming the adaptation keeps it transparent. Photo: Thirdman / Pexels

Adapting a tool is a clinical judgment call. Naming the adaptation keeps it transparent. Photo: Thirdman / Pexels

I’m also not claiming there’s no occupationally developed instrument anywhere. I’m asking because I want to know what people are actually using. If something validated for workers exists and is in use, that’s exactly what I’d like to hear about.

I’m also not claiming there’s no occupationally developed instrument anywhere. I’m asking because I want to know what people are actually using. If something validated for workers exists and is in use, that’s exactly what I’d like to hear about.

What I am saying is this: when we adapt, we should name it. Say which population the tool came from, which normative data we’re reading scores against, and which parts of the decision the tool can inform and which it can’t. That kind of transparency is what sport built into SCAT6’s own documentation. It’s worth carrying across along with the tool.

What I am saying is this: when we adapt, we should name it. Say which population the tool came from, which normative data we’re reading scores against, and which parts of the decision the tool can inform and which it can’t. That kind of transparency is what sport built into SCAT6’s own documentation. It’s worth carrying across along with the tool.

What I am saying is this: when we adapt, we should name it.

What I am saying is this: when we adapt, we should name it.

What naming an adaptation can look like

What naming an adaptation can look like

The items below are practice recommendations for documentation. They are not a validated protocol, and they do not replace clinician judgment. They are a way to make sure the next person reading the file knows what was actually done.

The items below are practice recommendations for documentation. They are not a validated protocol, and they do not replace clinician judgment. They are a way to make sure the next person reading the file knows what was actually done.

When a sport-derived tool is used after a suspected workplace head injury, the note can record:

When a sport-derived tool is used after a suspected workplace head injury, the note can record:

  1. Which tool and version was used, for example SCAT6, and who administered it.

  2. Which sections were changed or skipped, such as memory questions rewritten for the work site, and what was asked instead.

  3. What the result was compared against: a prior baseline if one exists, published norms, or nothing.

  4. When it was done relative to the injury and the shift, and what the worker had just been doing.

  5. What the result was used for, and what it was not used for. A screening result can support a referral. It is not a diagnosis, and it does not clear anyone to return to work.

  1. Which tool and version was used, for example SCAT6, and who administered it.

  2. Which sections were changed or skipped, such as memory questions rewritten for the work site, and what was asked instead.

  3. What the result was compared against: a prior baseline if one exists, published norms, or nothing.

  4. When it was done relative to the injury and the shift, and what the worker had just been doing.

  5. What the result was used for, and what it was not used for. A screening result can support a referral. It is not a diagnosis, and it does not clear anyone to return to work.

That is documentation, not diagnosis. It also makes a treating clinician’s job easier, because it tells them what the number can and cannot carry.

That is documentation, not diagnosis. It also makes a treating clinician’s job easier, because it tells them what the number can and cannot carry.

How this page relates to ICAT

How this page relates to ICAT

Industrial Concussion Institute is working on the workplace side of this question. ICAT is a structured recognition and referral tool for trained first aiders and safety teams. It does not diagnose concussion, and it does not clear anyone to return to work. Medical disposition and restrictions belong to an appropriately licensed healthcare professional. The employer applies those restrictions to the job.

Industrial Concussion Institute is working on the workplace side of this question. ICAT is a structured recognition and referral tool for trained first aiders and safety teams. It does not diagnose concussion, and it does not clear anyone to return to work. Medical disposition and restrictions belong to an appropriately licensed healthcare professional. The employer applies those restrictions to the job.

The sources behind ICI articles are collected on the Research page.

The sources behind ICI articles are collected on the Research page.

The question

The question

Sport spent more than two decades building instruments for its own population, and it was honest about their limits. I admire that. The workplace version of that work is still an open question, and I’d rather learn from the people doing it than guess.

Sport spent more than two decades building instruments for its own population, and it was honest about their limits. I admire that. The workplace version of that work is still an open question, and I’d rather learn from the people doing it than guess.

If you assess workers after a head injury: what are you actually using, and what did you have to modify to make it fit?

If you assess workers after a head injury: what are you actually using, and what did you have to modify to make it fit?

Please leave out anything that identifies your employer or your workers. You can share a de-identified practice through the contact page. I read every response.

Please leave out anything that identifies your employer or your workers. You can share a de-identified practice through the contact page. I read every response.

Sources

Sources

  • Echemendia RJ, et al. Introducing the Sport Concussion Assessment Tool 6 (SCAT6). Br J Sports Med. 2023;57(11):619-621 (DOI 10.1136/bjsports-2023-106849; PMID 37316207).

  • Echemendia RJ, et al. Sport Concussion Assessment Tool 6 (SCAT6). Br J Sports Med. 2023;57(11):622-631 (DOI 10.1136/bjsports-2023-107036; PMID 37316203).

  • Patricios JS, et al. Consensus statement on concussion in sport: the 6th International Conference on Concussion in Sport, Amsterdam, October 2022. Br J Sports Med. 2023;57(11):695-711 (DOI 10.1136/bjsports-2023-106898; PMID 37316210).

  • Patricios JS, et al. Introducing the Sport Concussion Office Assessment Tool 6 (SCOAT6). Br J Sports Med. 2023;57(11):648-650 (DOI 10.1136/bjsports-2023-106860; PMID 37316211).

  • Aubry M, et al. Summary and agreement statement of the First International Conference on Concussion in Sport, Vienna 2001. Br J Sports Med. 2002;36(1):6-10 (DOI 10.1136/bjsm.36.1.6; PMID 11867482).

  • McCrory P, et al. Summary and agreement statement of the 2nd International Conference on Concussion in Sport, Prague 2004. Br J Sports Med. 2005;39(4):196-204 (DOI 10.1136/bjsm.2005.018614; PMID 15793085).

  • American College of Occupational and Environmental Medicine (ACOEM). Traumatic Brain Injury Guideline: Sport Concussion Assessment Tool (SCAT) for TBI; Immediate Post-Concussion Assessment (ImPACT) for TBI. In: ACOEM Practice Guidelines, Traumatic Brain Injury Guideline. Reed Group; 2025. Public copy adopted in the California DWC MTUS (August 2025 update): https://www.dir.ca.gov/dwc/DWCPropRegs/2025/MTUS-Evidence-Based-Update-August/Traumatic-Brain-Injury-Guideline.pdf

  • Iverson GL, Koehle MS. Normative data for the modified Balance Error Scoring System in adults. Brain Inj. 2013;27(5):596-599 (DOI 10.3109/02699052.2013.772237; PMID 23473405).

  • Kontos AP, et al. False-positive rates and associated risk factors on the Vestibular-Ocular Motor Screening and modified Balance Error Scoring System in US military personnel. J Athl Train. 2022;57(5):458-463 (DOI 10.4085/1062-6050-0094.21; PMID 35696602).

  • Echemendia RJ, et al. Introducing the Sport Concussion Assessment Tool 6 (SCAT6). Br J Sports Med. 2023;57(11):619-621 (DOI 10.1136/bjsports-2023-106849; PMID 37316207).

  • Echemendia RJ, et al. Sport Concussion Assessment Tool 6 (SCAT6). Br J Sports Med. 2023;57(11):622-631 (DOI 10.1136/bjsports-2023-107036; PMID 37316203).

  • Patricios JS, et al. Consensus statement on concussion in sport: the 6th International Conference on Concussion in Sport, Amsterdam, October 2022. Br J Sports Med. 2023;57(11):695-711 (DOI 10.1136/bjsports-2023-106898; PMID 37316210).

  • Patricios JS, et al. Introducing the Sport Concussion Office Assessment Tool 6 (SCOAT6). Br J Sports Med. 2023;57(11):648-650 (DOI 10.1136/bjsports-2023-106860; PMID 37316211).

  • Aubry M, et al. Summary and agreement statement of the First International Conference on Concussion in Sport, Vienna 2001. Br J Sports Med. 2002;36(1):6-10 (DOI 10.1136/bjsm.36.1.6; PMID 11867482).

  • McCrory P, et al. Summary and agreement statement of the 2nd International Conference on Concussion in Sport, Prague 2004. Br J Sports Med. 2005;39(4):196-204 (DOI 10.1136/bjsm.2005.018614; PMID 15793085).

  • American College of Occupational and Environmental Medicine (ACOEM). Traumatic Brain Injury Guideline: Sport Concussion Assessment Tool (SCAT) for TBI; Immediate Post-Concussion Assessment (ImPACT) for TBI. In: ACOEM Practice Guidelines, Traumatic Brain Injury Guideline. Reed Group; 2025. Public copy adopted in the California DWC MTUS (August 2025 update): https://www.dir.ca.gov/dwc/DWCPropRegs/2025/MTUS-Evidence-Based-Update-August/Traumatic-Brain-Injury-Guideline.pdf

  • Iverson GL, Koehle MS. Normative data for the modified Balance Error Scoring System in adults. Brain Inj. 2013;27(5):596-599 (DOI 10.3109/02699052.2013.772237; PMID 23473405).

  • Kontos AP, et al. False-positive rates and associated risk factors on the Vestibular-Ocular Motor Screening and modified Balance Error Scoring System in US military personnel. J Athl Train. 2022;57(5):458-463 (DOI 10.4085/1062-6050-0094.21; PMID 35696602).

Portrait of Sheldon Victorine, MS, ATC, CSCS

About the author

Sheldon Victorine, MS, ATC, CSCS, is the Founder and Lead Researcher of the Industrial Concussion Institute. He specializes in workplace health, safety and ergonomics, with a clinical foundation as a certified athletic trainer and NSCA Certified Strength and Conditioning Specialist, after 7 years in the U.S. Navy. He writes evidence-informed tools and training that help workplaces recognize head injuries, refer workers to care and document what happened.

Sheldon Victorine, MS, ATC, CSCS, is the Founder and Lead Researcher of the Industrial Concussion Institute. He specializes in workplace health, safety and ergonomics, with a clinical foundation as a certified athletic trainer and NSCA Certified Strength and Conditioning Specialist, after 7 years in the U.S. Navy. He writes evidence-informed tools and training that help workplaces recognize head injuries, refer workers to care and document what happened.

Educational content only. Not medical advice.

Educational content only. Not medical advice.

© 2026 Industrial Concussion Institute LLC. All rights reserved.

© 2026 Industrial Concussion Institute LLC. All rights reserved.